I can't agree with you enough..I was blown away that they didn't offer it in a manual tranny. That, and the change in fuel economy is exactly why I am looking at an older one.
The salesman and his manager did try to tell me that the 2010 will get just as good gas mileage as the first generation; I asked why the sticker didn't show that, as well as anything I found on Honda's specs for the car. Get this, they said that other manufacturers weren't happy with the fact the Insight got such good mileage so Honda had to change how they advertised their mpgs, but I should expect to get at least 60-70 with a 2010.
I just smiled and told them only to call me if they got an older one in.
I'll call you this week.