There have been questions on when to change the CVT fluid. There has been pure confusion regarding the replacement of the CVT fluid filter.
Just about half of the Honda employees in sales, service, and parts that I have spoken to are not even aware that there is an inline CVT filter between the radiator and the CVT. Even those that are aware of the filter often say that Honda doesn't have a time life on it and therefore it should never be changed.
I changed my fluid and filter in April, when my I2 had 12k miles. Judging by the smell and color of the fluid, I would not want to change it much (if any) later than that. See
CVT Fluid/Filter Change for details.
It has long bothered me as to what was inside that filter. Was it a coarse screen mesh to catch big pieces in case the CVT has a catastrophic internal failure and that's why it has no life span? Or was it a fine paper filter to keep the fluid clean and keep wear down? If it was a fine filter, why no time change?
I finally got around to taking my old CVT filter apart. Surprise, the correct answer is B. Yes, it is indeed a very fine paper filter that catches most anything. Furthermore, it has a specific inlet and outlet and it is important to get the new one installed correctly.
Here's my beef with Honda. They say that filter will last the life of the car. By the time that filter clogs and the CVT craters, sure the life of the car is pretty much over. On the other hand, this filter does pick up minute particles. You can see by the pictures on the referenced thread that the magnetic chip detector did pick up quite a bit of material, so imagine how much made it to the filter and how much longer the CVT would last if the filter were kept clean. That puts a big variable on the life of the car.
My biggest problem with Honda's policy is heat. The CVT circulates fluid to the radiator for cooling. I suggest that each particle of debris that is caught by this filter restricts the flow of fluid through the radiator a little. By the time enough particles accumulate on the magnetic plug to coat it as much as mine was and to have fuzz sticking out 1/10 of a CM, I suggest that flow through the filter is "significantly" reduced. And this is only after 12k miles. Imagine how effective your CVT fluid flow through the radiator is at 25k, 50k, or more miles if this is the result of 12k.
I traded in my Insight for a CR-Z shortly afterwards, so I have no data on how the next 12k miles would pan out. Nor have I seen pictures of anyone else's mag plug on a CVT fluid change. I do know that my CR-Z will get a fluid and filter change in the 10k-12k range and I will compare the results.